Astronomers have suggested that some exoplanets previously considered unusually massive rocky worlds may actually be the result of measurement errors. Researchers have identified an unexpected pattern: all the candidates for these types of planets that they examined orbit highly active stars. This suggests that their masses may have been overestimated because of processes occurring on the surfaces of their host stars.
The objects in question are known as mega-Earths — hypothetical rocky planets whose masses are significantly greater than that of Earth. Their existence poses a challenge to modern models of planet formation because sufficiently massive solid cores are generally expected to attract large amounts of gas and gradually develop into planets with thick gaseous envelopes.
According to widely accepted models of planet formation, a rocky core with a mass approximately ten times that of Earth can begin rapidly accumulating gas from the surrounding protoplanetary disk. Under favorable conditions, such an object should become a gas-rich planet rather than remain an enormous rocky world.
However, observations have revealed several exoplanets that, according to measurements, have extremely large masses and relatively small radii. Their calculated densities suggest that heavy materials dominate their composition rather than hydrogen and helium.
Astronomers have proposed various scenarios to explain their existence. For example, a planet might have formed under unusual conditions or lost its original gaseous envelope because of intense radiation from its host star.
The new study, however, suggests considering a simpler possibility: some of these objects may not be as massive as previously believed.
To determine the masses of distant exoplanets, astronomers often use the radial velocity method. A planet’s gravitational pull causes its star to move slightly around their common center of mass. These movements produce small changes in the star’s spectrum, which can be used to calculate the planet’s mass.
The problem is that similar changes can also occur without a planet being involved. Starspots, magnetic fields, and other manifestations of stellar activity alter the shapes of spectral lines. As a result, measurements may contain additional signals that are difficult to distinguish from the gravitational influence of a planet.
In the new study, Casey Brinkman and Nicholas Cowan examined known supermassive rocky exoplanets and found that all of them orbit relatively active stars.
To assess stellar activity, the researchers used a specific indicator that characterizes a star’s chromospheric emission. In every system they examined, the value of this indicator exceeded the threshold established by the researchers.
According to the authors’ calculations, the probability that all these planets would happen to orbit active stars by chance is less than 1%.
At the same time, the researchers found no convincing physical mechanism explaining why extremely massive rocky planets should preferentially form around such stars.
The authors suggest that the unusual association between candidate mega-Earths and stellar activity points to systematic errors in determining planetary masses.
If stellar activity is not adequately accounted for, an exoplanet’s mass may be overestimated, making its calculated density significantly higher than its actual density.
The researchers also questioned the reliability of some statistical methods used to separate planetary signals from stellar noise. In particular, they examined models based on Gaussian processes, which are widely used to analyze radial velocity measurements.
This does not mean that these methods always produce incorrect results. However, the new study demonstrates how cautiously measurements from systems with active stars must be interpreted, especially when the resulting planetary properties contradict established models of planet formation.
If the hypothesis is confirmed, astronomers will need to reassess the properties of some known exoplanets. Objects that currently appear to be extraordinarily dense rocky worlds may turn out to be less massive planets that do not require unusual formation scenarios to explain their existence.
Nevertheless, the study does not prove that mega-Earths do not exist at all. The authors identified a statistical pattern and proposed an explanation for it, but further observations and independent mass measurements of individual planets are needed before definitive conclusions can be drawn.
The research highlights an important challenge in modern astronomy: even highly precise instruments cannot always unambiguously distinguish a planet’s weak signal from processes occurring on its host star.
Further studies of stellar activity may therefore change our understanding not only of individual exoplanets but also of the types of planets that can form throughout the universe.